Majorities and courts: a defence of political constitutionalism in liberal democracies

Cannilla Morozovich, A. L. (2019) Majorities and courts: a defence of political constitutionalism in liberal democracies. PhD thesis, University of Reading. doi: 10.48683/1926.00088502

Abstract/Summary

In this thesis I argue that, in liberal democracies, parliaments should enjoy sovereignty in constitutional decision making and I criticize the idea of judicial supremacy; this is the idea that courts should have the power to strike down legislation when they find it violates the basic values and principles of a constitutional order. After an introductory chapter where I explain the relevance and outline of my argument, in chapter two I critically examine three areas of disagreement between defenders and detractors of judicial supremacy: legal indeterminacy, the global judicialization of politics and the empirical question about the effects of courts in the protection of fundamental rights. In chapter three I tum to normative positivism in order to tie majority rule with the democratic authority of law and I also defend the desirability of judicial moral reasoning for the authority of law in liberal democracies. In chapter four I draw a line between imperfect yet full democracies and other political systems and I then use the distinction to support my argument in favour of parliamentary sovereignty in the former contexts. I also expand on what form this majoritarian democracy should take by incorporating agonistic critiques of liberalism into constitutional theory. In chapter five I develop a distinctive account of popular constitutionalism that acknowledges the legal nature of constitutions while defending popular and parliamentary sovereignty and I critically examine the relation between different forms of constitutionalism and the phenomena of populism. I conclude the thesis with a brief summary of my argument against strong judicial review of legislation.

Item Type	Thesis (PhD)
URI	https://reading-clone.eprints-hosting.org/id/eprint/88502
Identification Number/DOI	10.48683/1926.00088502
Divisions	Arts, Humanities and Social Science > School of Law
Download/View statistics	View download statistics for this item